The brief
In this illustrative project, a buyer needs 2,000 printed cartons for a new product. The two factories have quoted the same dimensions, board specification, quantity, print coverage and handover point. The buyer has asked for one production-colour proof before authorising the run. All figures below are hypothetical US dollars.
Put the quotes on the same basis
- Factory A: $0.74 per carton, plus $210 for setup and $50 for the proof. Total: 2,000 × $0.74 + $210 + $50 = $1,740, or $0.87 per carton.
- Factory B: $0.82 per carton including setup, with a $60 proof. Total: 2,000 × $0.82 + $60 = $1,700, or $0.85 per carton.
What changes the decision?
Factory B is $40 lower on the first order. For an identical repeat run, suppose both factories confirm in writing that the existing tooling can be reused and that no further proof is needed. At the quoted unit rates, Factory A would then cost $1,480 and Factory B $1,640. Reusability, artwork changes and price validity belong in the supplier’s written response before the buyer relies on that comparison.
What the buyer takes away
Keep the first order and the repeat order in separate columns. Compare the approved proof and confirm whether the quoted board, ink coverage and assembly match the brief. These numbers cover the specified factory order; freight, taxes and import charges require a separate calculation.
Download the editable comparison sheet or discuss a factory shortlist.